Now this really is a subject
that really that gets right up my back. Why is it necessary to write a story in
perfect English grammar, when most of the population in the UK would never know
English grammar if it hit them in the face? Those that do talk it are looked
upon as trying to be something they are not. With comments from the majority
like, “Listen to him/her with their airs and graces.”
Walk along an English street in any big town and ask a
direction or a question of a passer-by. Most will give you sentences with mms
and errs, mixed with the local dialect that leave you wishing you had not
bothered asking in the first place. In some cases after hearing the answer you can only scratch your head in a
state of confusion. It’s at that point you wonder if when you walked out of the
last shop you stepped through a time warp, and are now on doppelganger planet.
However, very few people of any age will answer you in plain English, and even
less of them will answer using English grammar.
STONEHENGE
Take the music industry and ask yourself, when was the
last time you heard a song that was being sung with English Grammar in mind? Yea right, let’s move on. Take Rap for
instance, a series of words spoken at speed with music thrown in to make it
sell. As yet I have not heard a Rapping song/whatever that sounds remotely like
the way we talk or the way we read. Then how do we expect our children that
have been at school for the best part of eleven to fourteen years to speak or
write properly?
My first school was in 1952 and a junior school, and
from that day forward my education was abysmal. It started in a dip where I lay
for ten years while the basics in education bounced off of my imagination. I
was twelve years old and there were far too many things to learn. Did I really
want to know how to make a fire extinguisher in science? Could I make one in
time to put out a raging fire in an emergency, and where would I find all of these tubes and
glasses?
WIDECOMBE IN THE MOOR
Dennis redfield
I was pulled out of a dream one morning in the middle
of a lesson by the history teacher, “Johnstone, when did the Normans arrive in
England?”
I focused my eyes once more as I scratched my head
before I looked around the room. The entire class was looking back at me waiting
for an answer. I replied with conviction, “It must have been last week, Sir, when
I was not at school.”
The class burst out laughing while the teacher banged
his forehead on the desk. While he was going through this self inflicted pain
his hand was pointing to the door. I stood up behind my desk to follow the pointing finger. I then walked to the classroom door
before stepping through it into the corridor. The sun was shining so I went home
and went fishing on the lake all day. It was not until the next day that the
same teacher told me, “I only wanted you to stand outside the door until the
end of the lesson. You never learned a thing yesterday.”
I was going to tell him that I never caught any fish either, but decided it might be to much information.
There were so many useless subjects being pushed
inside my head that there was no room for the ones that mattered, English
literature, English grammar, mathematics. There was never a correction for a
wrong spelling, just the red line denoting it was wrong. It was marked that way
I suppose, so that the twelve year old student would go and find out the correct way to
spell it. Let’s see now, where was the only dictionary in the school? Yes in
the school library with one major problem. The school library is out of bounds
to all except during reading lessons.
WASTWATER LAKE DISTRICT
Alan Cleaver
Now here I am on a Monday eager to find out why my
essay has had the word “FORREST” marked wrong. I was still wondering [or maybe
not] when the bell rang at four in the afternoon. Telling me that I can give my tired little brain a rest and go home,
and forget school. I had no homework, because in those years some of the
teachers were as lazy as the students they were teaching. When I get home that
night, school was just a memory. The sun is out and it’s free time. If the
teachers could not be bothered to teach me the correct way to spell the word
“FOREST” while in the classroom, then I can assure you all that there was not a
chance in hell I would learn it at home sitting on the river bank fishing.
Over the past fifty years I have taught myself to
write stories of my fantasies and imagination. I have learned to spell words
correctly while teaching myself history and mythology. The computer and the www
taught me geography which helps me in most of my stories. To be honest I have
taught myself to write by reading other authors stories.
Now I have another person telling me that my grasp of
English grammar is not to his way of thinking. You don’t say. Yes I am once again talking about editors. I am not
going to disagree with him because he is correct. I write as I think
and talk and I don't talk like the book of grammar. No one has yet told me that I don’t talk correct. No one has ever told me
that they could not understand what I am talking about. I have held my own in
conversations with teachers, lawyers, priests, and business men that were
talking no different than me.
Watch a film on television. Apart from the dated
films, how many people speak grammatically correct as they do in the written
story? I will leave you with these my thoughts for the moment, but I am not
finished on this subject, not by a long way.
Be well Ian
I had the same type of teachers, too lazy to correct, but heavy handed with the pen. My parents were German immigrants and I had to learn most of my English from books. Ibhad a tough time at school because my spoken English was far behind my comprehension and I was very shy. I know about "friends" that used to correct my grammar and I finally told them to stop. I said my first language wasn't English and that I really didn't care a hoot!
ReplyDeleteThank you for taking the time to comment.
DeleteI agree with You sir . But the case is different with the People whose first language isn't English they focus on English Grammar while neglecting Conversation due to this They encounter difficulties when they try to talk in English .
ReplyDeleteHere I would admit that I am not good at English at all and will be pleased if you help me in making Correction in English Grammar .